Carnegie Deli Murders

Murder Files Unsealed

The episode recounts the 2001 murder of aspiring actress Jennifer Stahl and three others in an apartment above the famous Carnegie Deli in New York City. The epsiode details the investigation, which led to the arrest and conviction of two men, Sean Salley and Andre Smith, for the robbery gone wrong that resulted in the tragic deaths. The episode highlights the victims' lives, their connections to Stahl's marijuana business, and the statements of surviving witnesses, ultimately revealing the motives and circumstances surrounding the crime.